As we reflect on 40 years of Rock Paper Scissors, we’ve found ourselves thinking a lot about traditions: the ones that bring people together, stand the test of time and become something you look forward to year after year. One of our favorite traditions happens to involve a little flour, A LOT of butter and a recipe that’s been passed down through Amanda’s family for generations.
What started as a Scottish family holiday tradition has become one of our favorite ways to celebrate the season, show appreciation for our clients and add a little sweetness to the end of the year. And while the cookies have evolved over time, the heart of the tradition remains the same.
The shortbread recipe originated in Scotland with Amanda’s great-grandfather, James S. Glennie. Back then, shortbread wasn’t made into individual cookies like it is today. It was rolled into one large sheet, almost like a cookie cake, stamped with decorative patterns and broken into pieces to share.
Fun Fact: For years, shortbread was typically only made by men in the family.
The family would go from house to house, sharing shortbread, carrying a bottle of Scotch, raising a toast and celebrating the holidays with friends and neighbors. This tradition was a way to connect with loved ones and share something special with the community.
Fun Fact: Amanda’s dad, Randy, brought back hand-kneading after deciding the stand mixer just didn’t deliver the same flavor.
So, how did a Scottish family recipe end up becoming a Rock Paper Scissors holiday tradition?
It started in the 1990s, when cookies occasionally made an appearance at office holiday events. Clients loved them, and the idea of gifting shortbread as a holiday thank-you started to take shape.
By the early 2000s, baking and gifting shortbread had become a regular part of our holiday routine. What better way to show appreciation for the people we work with than with something homemade?
Over the years, we’ve experimented with different ways to package and deliver them, from airtight tea tins to paper boxes during the pandemic. Eventually, we designed our own custom packaging to make the experience feel a little more like us.
If there’s one thing we can’t help ourselves from doing, it’s looking for ways to make things better. That applies to our work, our creative process, and, yes, our cookies.
Our packaging has evolved over the years, but so have the stamps we use to give each cookie its own personality. We started with simple terracotta and wooden stamps before exploring custom designs and shapes. Today, we’re always looking for new ways to make the cookies (and the experience of receiving them) a little more special.
We love taking something that already works, finding opportunities to improve it, and coming up with new ideas that make it even better. Whether we’re rethinking a brand, refining a strategy, or dreaming up cookie packaging, we’re always asking, “What else could we do?”
Every holiday season, our team gathers to mix, knead, stamp, bake, pack and distribute cookies to our clients. It’s a messy, fun, hands-on tradition that gives us a chance to slow down, spend time together and show our appreciation for the people who make our work meaningful.
Forty years of Rock Paper Scissors has given us plenty to celebrate, but it’s the little traditions, some old, some new, that remind us what matters most. We’re grateful for the clients, collaborators and friends who have been part of our journey, and we’re always happy to send a little shortbread their way.
The Art of Eating Shortbread
No cookie is complete without a yummy friend to join it in your belly. Here are some of the ways the RPS shortbread was traditionally enjoyed:
- The cozy ritual: Pair a cookie with your morning coffee or afternoon tea. The buttery, crumbly texture makes it the perfect companion to your favorite warm drink.
- The nightcap: Enjoy a piece of shortbread alongside a glass of Scotch. It’s the perfect way to wind down.
- Straight from the freezer: Shortbread tastes delicious frozen. The texture is a little firmer, and the buttery flavor still shines. (…but if we’re being honest, they rarely last long enough to make it to the freezer anyway.)
While the classics never disappoint, the RPS crew has a few other ways they like to enjoy their shortbread:
- Topped with jelly or jam
- Dipped into your favorite spread (honorable mentions for Nutella and Cookie Butter spread)
- Paired with your favorite ice cream (bonus points if you build a sundae!)
And while there are plenty of delicious ways to enjoy shortbread, the most popular method among the RPS crew is simple: straight from the bag to the mouth.
Here’s to another year of good ideas, great company and cookies worth sharing. Happy holidays from all of us at Rock Paper Scissors, and thank you again for forty amazing years!


